For a richer flavor, use real butter instead of butter-flavored shortening. Ensure the maraschino cherries are thoroughly drained to prevent the cookies from becoming soggy. Chilling the dough is crucial for easy handling and prevents the cookies from spreading too much during baking. Don't overbake the cookies; they should be lightly golden brown to maintain a soft texture. Store the cooled cookies in an airtight container at room temperature.
Peter Stanton
Jun 12, 2025I found that chilling the dough overnight made a huge difference. The cookies held their shape much better.
Zoie Klein
Oct 7, 2024My grandma used to make these! This recipe brought back so many memories. Thank you!
Melyssa Pricekerluke
Sep 8, 2024I added a little almond extract to the dough, and it gave the cookies a wonderful flavor.
Idella Stehr
Jul 29, 2024The cherries were indeed very hot after baking! I let them cool for a good hour before trying one.
Ruben Lemke
Jul 6, 2024These cookies were a hit at my Christmas party! The dough was a little tricky to work with, but the end result was worth it.